Skip to Content

20 Things You Should Never Throw in Your Compost Bin

20 Things You Should Never Throw in Your Compost Bin

Composting is a fantastic way to recycle organic waste and create nutrient-rich soil for your garden. However, not everything belongs in your compost bin. Adding the wrong items can slow down decomposition, attract pests, or even harm your plants.

To ensure your compost pile stays healthy and effective, avoid these 20 items that should never end up in your compost bin. By knowing what to exclude, you’ll create better compost and keep your garden thriving.

Meat and Fish Scraps

Meat and Fish Scraps
© Gardening Know How

Meat and fish can attract unwanted pests to your compost bin, creating a smelly and unpleasant environment. While it’s tempting to discard leftover scraps, they can harbor harmful bacteria. Moreover, these items break down at a much slower rate compared to plant-based materials, disrupting the composting process. Consider alternative methods for disposing of meat and fish waste to maintain a healthy compost bin. By keeping these out, you ensure your compost remains balanced and efficient. This practice also prevents attracting rodents and other scavengers to your garden area.

Dairy Products

Dairy Products
© Harvard Health

Dairy products, such as milk, cheese, and yogurt, can cause similar issues as meat and fish when added to compost. These items attract pests and create unpleasant odors as they decompose. Also, dairy takes longer to break down, which can slow the entire composting process. Instead of adding these to your compost, consider using them in other ways, such as feeds for animals if appropriate. Keeping dairy out of the compost bin helps maintain a clean and efficient composting operation.

Oils and Greasy Foods

Oils and Greasy Foods
© Harvard Health

Oils and greasy foods disrupt the composting environment by coating materials and slowing down decomposition. Additionally, they attract pests, much like meat and dairy products. The presence of oil can also create water-repellent barriers within the compost, preventing moisture from penetrating and aiding decomposition. To avoid these issues, dispose of oils and greasy foods through other means, or consider recycling used oils where facilities exist. Maintaining grease-free compost ensures healthier plant growth and more efficient nutrient cycling.

Pet Waste

Pet Waste
© yourcleanwater.org

Pet waste, including feces from cats and dogs, can introduce harmful bacteria and parasites to your compost. These pathogens pose health risks to humans, especially if the compost is used on edible plants. Besides the health concerns, pet waste produces unpleasant odors that can be off-putting. It’s safer to dispose of pet waste in the trash or consider specialized composting systems designed for pet waste. Keeping regular compost free of pet waste ensures a safe environment for gardening. This practice supports a hygienic and flourishing garden setting.

Diseased Plants

Diseased Plants
© Better Homes & Gardens

Diseased plants should never find their way into your compost bin. The pathogens responsible for plant diseases can survive the composting process and spread to healthy plants when the compost is used. This can lead to widespread issues in your garden, negating the benefits of composting. Instead, dispose of diseased plants through trash pick-up services or consider burning them if regulations permit. By excluding these from your compost, you protect the health of your garden and promote robust plant growth.

Treated Wood Products

Treated Wood Products
© BB&S Lumber

Treated wood products contain chemicals that resist decomposition, making them unsuitable for composting. These chemicals can leach into your compost, potentially harming plants and soil life. Avoid adding any wood that has been painted, stained, or chemically treated to your compost pile. Look for untreated wood alternatives if you need to add wood materials. By preventing treated wood from entering your compost, you ensure it remains a safe and nourishing environment for garden plants.

Coal or Charcoal Ash

Coal or Charcoal Ash
© Earth.com

Coal and charcoal ash can contain harmful substances that are not suitable for composting. These ashes may alter the pH balance of your compost, making it too alkaline for most plants. Instead of adding these to your compost, consider using small amounts of wood ash, which can provide beneficial nutrients in moderation. Keeping coal and charcoal ash out maintains a balanced and healthy compost pile. This practice supports a thriving garden environment and enhances soil fertility naturally.

Invasive Weed Seeds

Invasive Weed Seeds
© Organic Plant Care LLC

Invasive weed seeds can survive the composting process and germinate once the compost is applied to your garden. This can lead to an infestation of unwanted plants, undermining your gardening efforts. Carefully remove and dispose of invasive weeds before composting garden waste. Alternatively, use methods like solarization to kill weed seeds before adding them to your compost. By keeping invasive seeds out, you maintain control over your garden and prevent the spread of unwanted species.

Glossy or Coated Paper

Glossy or Coated Paper
© IndiaMART

Glossy and coated papers, such as magazines and flyers, contain inks and coatings that are not suitable for composting. These materials break down slowly and can introduce toxins into your compost. Instead, recycle glossy papers through municipal recycling programs. By keeping these materials out, you support a cleaner and toxin-free composting process. This ensures that the compost is beneficial when added to your garden, promoting a healthy and vibrant plant life.

Non-Biodegradable Materials

Non-Biodegradable Materials
© The Shakti Plastic Industries

Non-biodegradable materials like plastics and metals have no place in a compost bin. They do not break down and can contaminate your compost with harmful residues. Always sort and recycle non-biodegradable items appropriately. By keeping these materials out of your compost, you ensure that the end product is pure and facilitates healthy plant growth. This practice contributes to a more sustainable gardening approach and reduces your environmental footprint.

Synthetic Fertilizers

Synthetic Fertilizers
© Gardening Know How

Synthetic fertilizers can disrupt the natural balance of your compost by introducing chemicals that are not compatible with organic decomposition. These fertilizers can lead to nutrient imbalances and potentially harm beneficial microbes within the compost. Instead, focus on natural amendments to enhance your compost pile. By avoiding synthetic fertilizers, you maintain a harmonious and productive composting process. This supports the growth of healthy, chemical-free plants in your garden.

Black Walnut Leaves

Black Walnut Leaves
© National Park Service

Black walnut leaves contain juglone, a natural compound that can inhibit the growth of certain plants. Adding these leaves to your compost can unintentionally damage susceptible plants when the compost is used. Instead, dispose of black walnut leaves separately or use them as mulch under juglone-tolerant plants. By keeping these leaves out, you protect your garden from potential harm and ensure your compost supports diverse plant life. This practice promotes a safe and flourishing garden environment.

Citrus Peels

Citrus Peels
© Epicurious

Citrus peels break down slowly and can make your compost pile more acidic, which is not ideal for most plants. Additionally, the strong scent of citrus can deter beneficial insects from your compost. To avoid these issues, use citrus peels in homemade cleaning solutions or add them to the trash. By excluding citrus peels, you maintain a balanced and effective composting process. This supports the growth of a wide range of plants and enriches your garden soil naturally.

Onion and Garlic Scraps

Onion and Garlic Scraps
© Food & Wine

Onion and garlic scraps can create strong odors that deter beneficial organisms in your compost. Additionally, these items decompose slowly and can lead to an imbalance in your compost pile. Consider using them to create natural pest repellents or discard them through regular waste channels. By keeping onion and garlic out of your compost, you ensure a more pleasant and efficient decomposition process. This practice supports a thriving composting environment and encourages nutrient-rich soil development.

Toxic Plants

Toxic Plants
© MedicalNewsToday

Toxic plants, including poison ivy and oleander, should not be added to your compost as they retain their harmful properties even after decomposition. Handling compost containing these plants can pose health risks. Safely dispose of toxic plant materials through waste collection services or designated hazardous waste facilities. By preventing toxic plants from entering your compost, you protect both your garden and personal health. This ensures a safe and enjoyable gardening experience for everyone involved.

Colored Newspaper

Colored Newspaper
© Kevin Lee Jacobs

Colored newspaper pages often contain inks that can introduce unwanted chemicals into your compost. These chemicals may inhibit the growth of plants and disrupt the composting process. Instead, use black-and-white newspaper pages or recycle colored ones through appropriate channels. Keeping colored newspapers out preserves the purity of your compost and supports a healthier garden ecosystem. This choice promotes sustainable gardening practices and enhances the overall quality of your garden’s soil.

Eggshells

Eggshells
© Birds and Blooms

Whole eggshells take a considerable amount of time to break down in a compost pile. While they can provide calcium when crushed and in moderation, they can also attract pests if left whole. To utilize eggshells effectively, crush them before adding to your compost or use them directly in the garden as snail deterrents. By managing eggshells properly, you enhance the efficiency of your composting process and contribute to a more vibrant garden environment.

Large Branches

Large Branches
© TreeLocate

Large branches take an extraordinarily long time to decompose, which can stall the composting process. Their size can also prevent proper aeration and mixing in the compost pile. Instead, cut branches into smaller pieces or consider using them as firewood or mulch. Keeping large branches out of your compost ensures a more efficient and balanced breakdown of organic materials. This practice supports quicker composting cycles and healthier soil for your plants.

Bread and Pasta

Bread and Pasta
© Times Food

Bread and pasta can attract pests to your compost bin, much like meat and dairy products. These food scraps can also cause mold growth, which disrupts the composting process. Consider using leftover bread and pasta in creative recipes or dispose of them through regular waste channels. By keeping these items out of your compost, you maintain a cleaner and more efficient composting process. This helps in producing high-quality compost for your garden and reduces waste.

Salted and Pickled Foods

Salted and Pickled Foods
© Epicurious

Salted and pickled foods introduce excess salt into your compost, which can be detrimental to plant health. High salt levels can hinder the growth of plants and harm beneficial organisms in your compost. Dispose of these foods through regular waste channels or find alternative uses for them. By keeping salted and pickled items out of your compost, you ensure the development of healthy, nutrient-rich soil. This supports the growth of a wide variety of plants in your garden.